Appliance Error Code Guide Codes, causes & fix order
Repair or replace

Repair or Replace? The Formula That Decides It

This is not a feeling about the machine. It is a comparison of what the repair costs against what the next few years of owning a new one would cost — and the numbers are easier to get than most owners expect.

Reviewed against parts-trade experience Updated 16 November 2026 11 min read

The short answer

  • Repair when the part is moderate, the machine is under about half its expected life, and the fault does not involve the sealed system or the drum bearings.
  • Replace when the repair exceeds about half the price of a comparable new machine, or when the labour is the whole bill.
  • Always add delivery, installation and disposal to the "replace" side, and the risk of a new fault to both.
  • Never decide from a code alone — the same code can be a ten-minute clean or a drum-out job.

The formula, in plain terms

Write four numbers on one line:

  1. R — the quoted repair cost, parts and labour together.
  2. N — the price of a new machine of the same size and rough quality, plus delivery, installation and removal of the old one.
  3. L — the years you reasonably expect the repaired machine to last. A washer or dryer typically gives 8 to 12 years of service; a refrigerator 10 to 15; a dishwasher 8 to 12. Take the years it has already done off the top, then discount again for condition.
  4. E — the running-cost difference. A modern replacement is usually more efficient; that saving arrives every month for the life of the new machine, and it belongs on the replace side.

Then ask a single question: does the repair cost less than half of N, and does L leave you at least two more years of use? If both answers are yes, repair. If either is no, replacement is usually the better decision even before the inconvenience of a kitchen without a working machine is counted.

Why "half the price of new" is the right line

The half-price line is not arbitrary. A repair is a bet that the rest of the machine is sound; at half the price of new, you are accepting roughly the same risk as buying new for the other half, but with the rest of the machine's years already spent. Above that line, you are paying to restore an older machine to a value it can no longer reach.

The rule needs two corrections, and both matter:

  • Compare against remaining life, not age. A well-built machine at six years old may have another eight years in it; a cheap one at four years may be finished. Build quality and how it has been used matter more than the calendar.
  • Count the hidden costs on both sides. Replacement brings delivery, installation, a new machine's warranty (a real benefit), disposal, and possibly a change in connection or cabinet size. Repair brings the risk that the first fault reveals a second.

Which repairs land where

RepairTypical weightUsually worth it?
Drain pump, inlet valve, door lockModerate part, accessibleYes, on almost any machine
Thermistor, fan motor, defrost heaterModerate partYes, if the cabinet is sound
Door seal, hose, filter housingLowAlways
Suspension rods / shock absorbersModerate, in setsYes, on a quiet, dry machine
Heating element, thermal fuseModerateYes, once the airflow cause is fixed
Control boardHigh part costOnly on a machine with years left
Drum bearing / spiderLabour dominatesRarely on a machine over ~7 years
Sealed system leak / compressorHigh, needs a licenceRarely; get a second opinion
Cracked tub, rusted cabinetStructuralNo

What the age tells you

Manufacturers do not publish a design life, and the honest answer is that it varies by platform and by use. Practical expectations from service experience:

ApplianceReasonable service lifeAt this age a major repair gets hard to justify
Washing machine8–12 years7+ years for bearings or a board
Tumble dryer10–15 years10+ for a board or a blower
Refrigerator10–15 years10+ for a sealed-system repair
Dishwasher8–12 years8+ for a pump and a leak together

Five questions to ask the technician

  1. What exactly failed, and how did you confirm it? A named part with a test beats a description of the symptom.
  2. Is this fault likely to have damaged anything else? A blown thermal fuse is a symptom; a restricted vent is the cause.
  3. What is the parts-and-labour split? It tells you whether you are paying for a part or for access.
  4. Does the repair carry a warranty, and for how long?
  5. If this were your machine, would you repair it? A straight answer here is worth more than any website's table, including this one.

Why a code cannot decide this for you

An error code reports a timeout or a signal, not a bill. A 5E on a washer can be a free filter clean or a pump replacement; a 22E on a fridge can be a fan motor or a defrost fault that iced it. The guide to reading codes explains why, and each brand guide gives the check order that turns the code into a part. Decide after the part is known, not before.

Cost is never a reason to keep using an unsafe machine. A burning smell, a scorched plug, water reaching electrics or a gas smell means stop using it now, whatever the repair arithmetic says.

Frequently asked questions

Should I repair a machine that is still under warranty?

Yes — use the warranty. Do not open the machine yourself if doing so could void it; call the manufacturer's service line first.

Is it ever worth repairing a 12-year-old washer?

Only for a cheap, accessible part and only if the drum, bearings and cabinet are sound. At that age a major repair is money spent on the last years of an old machine.

Do new appliances fail more than old ones?

Modern machines have more electronics and shorter warranty periods, so a new machine is not risk-free. That is one reason a moderate repair on a sound machine is often the better value, not just the cheaper option.

Does efficiency really change the decision?

Sometimes. For a fridge or a washer used daily, an efficiency improvement compounds over years. For a dryer used occasionally, it rarely decides anything.

Sources

  1. Editorial analysis of parts-trade cost structures: which parts are cheap but labour-heavy, and which are the reverse.
  2. Manufacturer support documentation on expected service life and repairability statements, accessed 16 November 2026.
  3. Energy-label efficiency data published by manufacturers and by national labelling schemes.

General guidance only, with no prices, because repair costs vary by country, city, brand and labour rate. Apply the formula to your own quotes. Safety-related work — gas, mains wiring, sealed refrigeration — must be done by a qualified technician.